I did something a few days ago that I’m slightly ashamed of and loathe to admit out loud: I fired up ChatGPT and entered the following prompt: Give me an idea for a sequel to No Time For Kings, an eco-thriller by Mark Petruska.

Ouch. I know!! I feel like a hypocrite after steadfastly dissing AI. I hadn’t given ChatGPT so much as a second thought since leaving TobacCo ten months ago; my CheeseGov job is blessedly AI-free. But, as much as I would love to start writing a sequel – the itch is strong these days – coming up with a decent story has proven challenging. At best, I have a concept of a plan. I figured it wouldn’t hurt to check in with our robot overlords, see if they could help jumpstart the process.

Things did not start out promisingly. It took ChatGPT five tries to get the right No Time for Kings, even though I’d supplied the author’s name. Funny, there’s only one other novel I’m aware of with the same title, so this made me extra skeptical. But after a series of repeated WRONG AUTHOR, DUMMY! replies, it finally got it right.

(Well, mostly. There is no Ethan Granger in my novel, but there is an Evan Gaffner – further proof you should never take AI as gospel.)

Much to my surprise, ChatGPT spit out a very detailed response that included a title, premise, plot, and themes. Even more shocking, it was pretty good! Not a direction I was considering, but one that actually makes a ton of sense. It’s a very logical next-step-in-the-journey for our intrepid heroine and moves the story to the present day admirably.

Rather than co-opting Balki’s “Dance of Joy,” I was actually a bit torn, because this creates a real dilemma. I feel like a cheat even turning to AI in the first place. I’ll bet you a dollar to a doughnut (what does that mean, anyway?!) Stephen King did not got his idea for Doctor Sleep, his sequel to The Shining, through a computer-generated prompt. And yet, I can’t unsee what I saw, ya know?

I’m trying hard to justify using this ill-gotten knowledge for good. First step: quit being so overdramatic! Maybe I just need to think of this as a brainstorming session…albeit, a brainstorming session with The Terminator. It’s not like I asked ChatGPT to write a freakin’ sequel. There are two pages’ worth of suggestions, most of which I would discard, though at its most basic, I do like the general plot. I see a great opportunity to combine my ideas with some of this other T-800 stuff to coax out a decent story.

Really curious for your thoughts.


I was waiting for an elevator at CheeseGov last week and did a double take when I saw Laverne and Shirley staring back at me from a giant monitor.

“Hey, I didn’t know it was Bring Your Pets to Work Day!” I said out loud with a chuckle. Which was weird, because I was the only one in the lobby at the time.

Every week our internal newsletter features a Show Us Your Pets segment where employees submit photos of and stories about their beloved furry companions. This is by far the most popular column in the newsletter; the waiting list is three months’ long, and yeah, I’d forgotten that I even submitted a Laverne and Shirley feature back in October. Seeing them pop up onscreen unexpected like that was a happy surprise (though for a brief moment I thought I was hallucinating). Several people commented on their names and/or their general cuteness. The native Wisconsinites especially loved the pop culture reference.

It’s still a little odd, this whole flex space thing. Every morning when I get to work, I play a little game I like to call, Where Will I Sit Today? Though mostly, it’s one of the same two spots – one a private cubicle in the corner, the other a window seat (but not the high-traffic spot at the end of the hallway). Which one I snag depends on several factors: traffic on the Beltline, my workload, the weather, and how social (or anti) I feel on any given day. Wouldn’t you know it though, I always end up at the same desk when working from home.

No big plans this weekend. It’s going to be cold and maybe a little snowy, but most of the heavy stuff is heading north. We plan to head to Janesville to shop at Woodman’s and stop by the brand new Raising Cane’s for lunch (being a fella who used to drive five hours for chicken fingers, this pleases me to no end).

Oh, and something about a big football game on Sunday…? (Please please please please PLEASE win, Eagles!)


55 responses to “Brainstorming with The Terminator”

  1. I’m also rooting heavily for the Eagles although I probably won’t watch since you-know-who will be there. Blech. Cute kitties, they’re famous now! I don’t think there’s anything wrong with using Chat GPT to guide some storylines; you’ll do the actual writing and the tweaking of the plot.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Ugh…but the one saving grace? He hates the Eagles after they snubbed his invitation to visit the White House, and he hates the Chiefs because of the Taylor Swift connection. No matter who wins, he’ll be fuming.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. I’m certain that Danielle Steele gets her tried and trite plots by pulling mix & match ideas from a hopper. If she can write countless books with Stainless Steele heroines and make big bucks in the process, why shouldn’t you use ChatBox to get you started?

    Liked by 2 people

    1. “Tried and trite” plots…ha. Love that! Can’t say I’ve read even a single page of a Danielle Steele book ever, but it doesn’t sound like I’m missing much.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. As long as you don’t let chatGPT write the book, I say take your inspiration anywhere you can get it. Maybe Laverne and Shirley can make a cameo ( or is that cateo? ) appearance.
    We’re due for more snow Sunday morning… to which I say, Go Birds!
    🦅

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Inspiration is one thing, plagiarism is something else entirely. Thank you for your wisdom! And I do like the idea of making L&S characters in the new novel. My protagonist could totally be a cat lady!

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Oops. Probably should have read River’s comment before I wrote my own. 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

  4. Why not go with the suggestions? The basic premise? Is using AI for help so different than seeking the same thing from humans who read the book and might have ideas? I see it as a useful nudge. What I really want to note is that Cheese.gov has a DEI program still on the agenda for it’s employees with no mention in the title of things like ending/termination/getting rid of… I want to hope that this means a shot directly to the Trump/Musk oligarchy and if so- YAY for Cheese.gov!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you for talking me through it, Deb. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with seeking help from AI per se; I guess I’m just bummed that I didn’t think of the idea myself. I’ll be damned if I give ChatGPT credit in the acknowledgment section (though maybe I’ll thank Arnold Schwarzenegger).

      DEI is still alive and well at CheeseGov until we’re told otherwise! Our governor is especially fired up these days. You don’t wanna mess with Tony.

      Liked by 2 people

  5. I have no problems with AI generated suggestions. Have you ever heard that there are no new story ideas? Mark Twain believed that all ideas are essentially combinations of old concepts. You could have possibly googled tropes or ideas for your genre for the same type of story and came up with those same suggestions. That probably wouldn’t have bothered you coming out of Google. (?)

    On a similar note, I love public domain materials. Of my twenty-one books, five have an old detective noir story woven into them from one of those old dime detective books. I changed names, dialogue, and didn’t use anything word-for-word, but the entire story is played out in my book by my characters – usually as a subplot. In no way do I feel this is plagiarism. Public domain materials are there for our use, and I love the idea of breathing life into an old, obscure, very short story. I don’t go into details, but in each book, I give a “nod” to the author and their story.

    Use the idea. Your first book is great. Now take that idea and make the second book just as great!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re right: I wouldn’t have minded Google so much. I just need to think of this as an even more efficient option.

      I never would have thought of borrowing public domain materials; that’s a great idea!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Sunday is just another Sunday to us

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well, here’s hoping your state comes through for me!

      Liked by 1 person

  7. I am completely against generative AI. It’s trained to steal the work of creatives, without compensation. It’s yet another way to keep artists, writers, and others from making a living. However, AI can in some cases be helpful to creatives and those with disabilities:https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/artificial-intelligence-will-not-replace-but-devalue-artists/

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I share your feelings, believe me. Which is why I was so torn. But this feels different because it’s expanding upon the themes of my own novel. At least it’s helped get the wheels turning!

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Oh, I love the idea taking a look at AI’s suggestions. I think that’s the perfect way to use AI. It’s brainstorming. You’re not getting AI to write it. You’re picking and choosing . . . that’s what every writer does. I gotta ask too: Did you create the artwork on the cover of your book or did Booklocker come up with? Good luck, you’ll get there.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Brian! The Booklocker package included a cover from a professional graphic designer. I told him exactly what I wanted: a ship, helicopters, the earth, red to represent spilled blood, and green to tie in with the environmental theme. I love what he came up with; he totally captured my vision!

      Liked by 1 person

  9. i’d say take suggestions from wherever they come – i’m personally not on board with ai yet, but it you’re not stealing someone’s idea, then what’s the harm in it? it originated from your idea after all

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks, Beth. This seems to be the general consensus. I can’t very well rob myself!

      Liked by 1 person

  10. I love Laverne and Shirley’s celebrity status…and your adventure into ChatGPT for storyline inspo. So intriguing! 😜🥰😜

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I just hope those two don’t let it go to their heads!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Star power, baby. They’ve got star power! 😎

        Liked by 1 person

  11. Well, you’re brave to put your AI query in print. Now, when you’re featured on Oprah for your next book, and your fame surpasses your wildest dreams, there will be a small but vocal subset of haters dissing you from all corners of the Internet. And Rivergirl may be at the vanguard! 🤣
    Oh yeah, the NotSoSuperBowl. Thanks for the reminder. I think I’ll take the batteries out of the remote control and hide them. Then again, the Husband isn’t a big watcher. He may turn it on for a few minutes, but I’ll make him put on the headphones so I don’t hear the annoying din of screaming fans. Hopefully he’ll tire of it in short order and we can watch Shetland on Britbox instead.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Haha…dare to dream! I’d love to be a popular enough writer to receive scorn from all corners of the internet. Not that there’s any reason for that, judging from most of the responses here!

      The Super Bowl is a lot more fun when your team is playing. For us, it’s all about the snacks. I saw a meme that said this is the one day of the year you can eat dip for dinner, ha.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I totally disagree. There are many days when dip is appropriate for dinner!

        Liked by 1 person

  12. Oh, and I love the Show Us Your Pet segment! I want to put my furry and finned friends on there!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Come work for CheeseGov and I can hook you up!

      Liked by 1 person

  13. Laverne and Shirley – they’re stars!

    I think brainstorming with AI is a really interesting thing to try. Love how you say that you can’t unsee it – but by the time the book is written, edited, edited, and edited, it’ll all be you!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. And it’s not like it’s some spectacularly original plot idea. It’s easily something I could have come up with on my own…I just had a different idea but was struggling with how to execute it. This helps!

      Liked by 1 person

  14. I love that picture of Laverne and Shirley! And when you said, “where will I sit today?” it made me think of cats, because they play that game every day too. So, your cats must be rubbing off on you!

    Sending you and Tara well wishes as you head to Woodman’s on the Saturday before the Super Bowl!

    My husband is also rooting for the Eagles because he can’t stand the other team. As for me, I’m just rooting for good commercials. 🤣

    Liked by 1 person

    1. At least with the cats, they’re going to either be sitting on me or Tara at some point. Probably both of us.

      I really wish I’d seen your comment before heading out yesterday. Woodman’s was an absolute zoo. It didn’t take us long to realize the error of our ways!

      Liked by 1 person

  15. That’s an interesting use of AI. Writers get their inspiration from many sources, so this seems as legit as others.

    We won’t be watching the SB this year. A) I don’t care about either team, and B) I don’t want to risk seeing Musk’s play toy on the big screen.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I don’t want to see him there either. Hoping he “accidentally” gets tackled by a pair of 400-lb. linemen and suffers a concussion (not that we’d be able to tell the difference), along with a few broken bones.

      Like

  16. I’m having trouble commenting suddenly on your blog. When I hit the Comment button, I get a popup that says, Sorry, your comment can’t be posted.

    Like

    1. looks like it’s working today….it’s just been your and Betsy’s blogs.

      anyhoo, it must have been a shock to see your cats on the screen in the lobby🤣 what a nice newsletter feature!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Every once in awhile, something goes wonky with commenting. Glad it started working for you again. And yes, it’s a fun feature for sure. I’ve struck up more conversations with coworkers based on their pets than their actual jobs!

        Like

  17. After my one adventure years ago when I used ChatGPT to write a story that I shared on my blog, I’ve never touched it again. No one liked the story I wrote, but I’m guessing it’s more sophisticated now.

    Looking forward to the Super Bowl, less for the game & commercials than for this seemingly never-ending football season to be over. They do drag this stuff out, don’t they?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Great game (given that I desperately wanted the Chiefs to lose)! Unlike you though, I wish football season lasted all year long. The next six months feel interminably long.

      The fact that they didn’t like your ChatGPT story just goes to show how much they appreciate your writing!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I was rooting for the Eagles too. I figure Taylor Swift’s boyfriend’s team has had its day in the sun. I’m flattered by your twist on my ChatGPT experience. Thanks!

        Liked by 1 person

  18. I worked on a team made up of computer scientists, real academics (I definitely do mean the shade), small business folks, and military types for a while. As you can imagine, communication was challenging. No one would post in Slack. Everyone had their favorite communication system – some people would only communicate using their personal phones (no records in case we’re subpoenaed!), some only in writing/email (must keep records in case we’re subpoenaed), and some would not talk to women because cooties. Anyway, into this dysfunctional work environment, I walk in. And I immediately started a “V.I.P. – Very Important Pets” Slack thread and it was OBVIOUSLY the only one that everyone posted to. I mean, we’re all just working to support our pets, right?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is great! They say people like to talk about themselves, but in my experience as well, I think they really just want to talk about their pets. It’s a great way to humanize our coworkers too!

      Like

  19. Most inventions are built on the shoulders of other inventions. Does it matter if an invention came from a robot? Scour it, twist it, and Mark it up – then it’ll be yours.

    I usually watch the Superbowl – often the only pro football game I’ll watch all year. This year I passed. Even so, I’m glad the Chiefs didn’t win another one. I still haven’t forgiven them for beating the Vikings back in Superbowl IV.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good thing you aren’t one to hold a grudge.

      “Scour it, twist it, and Mark it up” – I love that! Don’t be surprised to see it pop up in a future blog post.

      Liked by 1 person

  20. Hey I heard this podcast and thought of you. Not sure if you’ve heard of Joanna Penn? She talks a lot about AI for authors.
    Here she is interviewing Alicia Wright, an intellectual property lawyer from USA. The conversation is all about Generative AI for authors, partnering/collaborating/co-writing with AI, and copyright, ethical, and fair use issues.

    https://podcasts.apple.com/ee/podcast/fair-use-copyright-and-licensing-ai-and-the/id309426367?i=1000685597627

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m not familiar with Joanna Penn, but this sounds like a great podcast! Thank you for the link; I’ve bookmarked it for a near-future listen.

      Liked by 1 person

  21. I’ll be a million bucks that the Eagles beat Taylor’s team!

    Laverne and Shirley are famous and they probably don’t even know it. Or care.

    Look at you, cheating on your own brain with the AI stuff. 🤣

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ll *bet a million bucks

      Like

    2. Too bad you can’t back date a comment, huh? I’d be in awe of you. And possibly a little scared.

      Liked by 1 person

  22. The ideas for a sequel may sound good, but I’m wondering how the training data-set may lay a trap. If the set is like gossip from millions of shallow people talking about their valid and invalid opinions on quasi-related or qusi-relevant topics, it might be mildly interesting to the casual reader, or if trained on academic obfuscation, it might only be profound to reincarnated ancient Greek Philosophers. It might be better to think about what people don’t expect and base it on a dream you had after reading your book, after being hit on the head by falling plaster after an earthquake and winding up in a hospital bed. Your dream would probably make for a better sequel especially if ChatGPT appears in your dream as a dragon that eats your cats.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Funny, the approach I had was exactly that: going with something unexpected. I think this prompt helps give me some direction in making that happen.

      Liked by 1 person

  23. I’m like you, very snippy about AI writing tools, but I see more & more people using it in ways I can’t argue with.

    I know I may well give in and use it in the way you’ve mentioned, but a friend of mine has gone all out and trained the one she uses, so that it genuinely sounds like her. She finds it a tremendous help in producing content, but I don’t see myself going down that route as I *like* writing, and so have no desire to hand over the task. Cleaning though, send me an AI which’ll take over that chore and I’ll be signing right up! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I was required/strongly encouraged (take your pick) to use AI when writing for TobacCo, and hated that. It’s one thing to use it as a springboard for ideas, but in my mind, AI will never replace a talented human writer!

      Liked by 1 person

  24. […] in February, Laverne and Shirley were featured. Which is par for the course: the overwhelming majority of submissions are cats and dogs. […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Bijoux Cancel reply

THE LATEST SCOOP